U.S. Retail Organizations to Merge
April 23, 2009The National Retail Federation (NRF) and the Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA) will merge into one trade association that cohesively represents millions of workers in the industry, reports the Baltimore Business Journal.
“This is an historic time for our industry. The challenges and opportunities before our members are unprecedented. Now is the right time to bring these associations together,” said RILA Chairman Robert Niblock, CEO of Lowe’s Co. Inc. and NRF Chairman Myron Ullman, CEO of J.C. Penney Co. Inc., in a joint statement.
The combined group, which is currently unnamed, will give members a singular and stronger voice on policy, communications, and public affairs issues in Washington, D.C.; access to events and conferences for members of both groups; focused educational and operational services for independent retailers; and a fully-integrated staff.
Both groups will undergo a due diligence process to complete the merger, which has already been approved by their executive committees. Both associations’ boards must recommend the merger, and both memberships must approve it. The groups expect the deal to be completed by the summer, says the Baltimore Business Journal, with further details to be nailed out in the coming months.
Roslyn, Va.-based RILA has 200 member companies — from Abercrombie & Fitch to Wal-Mart — and it represents more than $1.5 trillion in sales. It employs 30 people.
The Washington, D.C.-based NRF is the world’s largest retail trade association with about 2,500 members, including department, specialty, discount, catalog, Internet, independent stores, chain restaurants, drugstores, and grocery stores. It employs about 100 workers.
Rebuttal to MasterCard Canada Assertions
April 22, 2009According to Canada NewsWire, MasterCard provided the following key points regarding interchange and debit and WayTooHigh.com replied below.
MASTERCARD CANADA: Canada has a well-functioning payments system that provides significant convenience and security to consumers and merchants. It has continued to operate effectively and drive commerce despite a global credit crisis. More than $240 billion in Canadian commerce is expedited on credit card systems annually.
WAYTOOHIGH: Nobody denies that payment cards are convenient and relatively secure. However, these benefits have nothing to do with interchange fees and do not confer upon issuing banks a blank check to extort supracompetitive profits from merchants and consumers through a hidden tax. Price-fixing is illegal!
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: A merchant that processes a credit card transaction enjoys guaranteed payment even at a time of increasing consumer default rates.
WAYTOOHIGH: Merchants are not permitted by the Visa and MasterCard rules to separately negotiate for payment guarantee services. This should be a negotiable service subject to competitive forces. Merchants should have the choice of whether to purchase these services from the card networks, from a third party, or not at all. The card networks and issuing banks already include the risk of default in the interest rates they charge to consumers. There is no justification for forcing merchants to cover this cost.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: Merchants benefit from increased sales, improved payment efficiency, reduced cash handling, customer convenience and satisfaction, e-commerce facilitation, international purchase handling, automatic currency conversion and settlement, among other benefits.
WAYTOOHIGH: There are no studies supporting the assertion that card usage increases sales, reduces checkout time, or increases consumer satisfaction. These are simple advertising puffery. To the extent that some of these claims are accurate, they are neither an excuse to price-fix supracompetitiveinterchange fees nor a justifiable expense to force upon merchants without negotiation. Just look at the tricks MasterCard and Visa (both were controlled by thousands of the same member banks) They offer sweepstakes, but the less expensive PIN-based debit cards are ineligible. They charge merchants for the high-costing affinity (frequent flier reward) signature cards, but many consumers never cash in those rewards. And now, the credit card companies are taking back the accrued rewards if a cardholder defaults by a single day, some unscrupulous companies are even paying cardholders to close their accounts, thus also losing those rewards.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: Interchange is a fee that passes between acquirers (who handle card processing for merchants) and card issuers. Issuers receive interchange to compensate them for significant costs and risks borne in offering credit cards including interest-free periods, account management, credit losses, fraud protection and processing.
WAYTOOHIGH: Regarding the assertion that merchants don’t pay interchange, the rebuttal is that the merchant discount rate automatically includes the interchange fee. The rest is mere semantics. Also, why would they talk about benefits to merchants from interchange fees if merchants weren’t paying those fees? Remember: interchange fees were designed forty-years ago, when retailers used antiquated manual credit card imprinters (ScanMyPhotos.com used these way back in the early 1990’s. The fee was cost-based; remember those stacks of carbon-copy receipts? Write a check, which passes through the Federal Reserve network and the there is no clearing (interchange) charge. Use a Starbucks gift card, and there is no interchange fee. Use a shopping mall card, good at multiple merchant locations, and there is no interchange charge. Buy a gift card for any retailer at a supermarket and even though there is a network of payment mechanisms in place, there is no interchange fee. Use a PIN-based Debit card in Canada and there is no interchange fee. Use a credit card in Iceland and… you get the idea. As to the “issuer compensation” argument, many of those expenses should be borne by the consumer, not the merchant (e.g. free funding period). Furthermore, the merchant should not be forced to purchase these alleged services as a price-fixed bundle. These should be available separately and negotiably.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard’s Canadian interchange rates remain well below those of other developed markets including the United States and below similar fees for American Express in Canada. A sampling of other countries with higher blended interchange rates than Canada include Argentina, Brazil, Germany, Greece, Indonesia, Japan, Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Switzerland, Turkey and Uruguay.
WAYTOOHIGH: The relevant comparison is not Canada v. Uruguay, it’s competitive v. anticompetitive. The fact that MasterCard’s supracompetitive interchange rates are not quite as inflated in other countries as they are in North America doesn’t render them legal. MasterCard and Visa boast 80% market power and are two giant cartels with, until recently, the same representatives on their board of directors. Collusion, greed, illegal price-fixing and hundreds of billions of dollars paid by consumers and merchants over the years is why this battle may be the largest antitrust case in U.S. history, and why the banks are engaged in a death-spiral battle against its two core customers – consumers and merchants.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard receives no revenue from interchange.
WAYTOOHIGH: MasterCard remains a puppet of the issuing banks, who receive enormous amounts of revenue from interchange. How does MasterCard explain the term “Merchant Discount Rate?” So, where do their revenues come from, then?
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: Consumers do not pay interchange fees nor merchant fees.
WAYTOOHIGH: As with the argument that merchants don’t pay interchange, MasterCard exalts form over substance. As a practical matter, merchants must build in their overhead costs into the costs of their products. Increasing interchange fees effectively increases the cost of goods just as would increasing the cost of the merchant’s rent or electricity. The nearly $60 billion dollars in merchant interchange fees in the U.S. last year came from somewhere! It is a hidden tax that ultimately, the consumers pay.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: Merchants who choose to accept credit cards pay to participate in exchange for the benefits received. The fee accounts for the multiple benefits received.
WAYTOOHIGH: The idea that merchants “choose” to accept credit cards is a myth. In reality, merchants must accept payment cards in order to stay in business. Furthermore, interchange is not cost-based. If it were, it would be far, far lower. Look at the European Union, where cross-border interchange is mandated to be cost based by law. For Ecommerce businesses, like ScanMyPhotos.com and millions of other online companies we are forced to accept Visa and MasterCard – they have an 80% market power over the industry. Their millions of dollars invested in TV commercials training consumers not to pay with cash is all the more reason why MasterCard and Visa are like drug dealers, they get consumers trained and then force them to use their products. Yes, force, and we can explain why.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: Merchants pay a merchant fee established by their acquirer, not MasterCard. Interchange forms a portion, but not all, of that merchant fee.
WAYTOOHIGH: Interchange accounts for the vast majority of the merchant discount fee and is non-negotiable. The merchant discount fee is always higher than the interchange fee, meaning that merchants effectively pay interchange. If the truth were otherwise, we’d have acquirer lawsuits against the networks and the issuers. Get real, it’s all about MasterCard. Until recently, MasterCard and Visa were just brands (trade associations) fully owned by the banks. Whether the fees go to the banks or the two giant credit card association, the same pockets were being enriched.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard’s 2008 adjustment to interchange rates was the first in seven years. Some rates were reduced.
WAYTOOHIGH: Whether or not that’s true, it doesn’t change the fact that the rates are much higher than they would be in a competitive environment (assuming they’d exist at all). Some rates were 300% higher than in 1999. Without warning, millions of merchants receive a twice yearly letter explaining the new rates, just days prior to it taking effect.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: A merchant can obtain his MasterCard interchange rates via http://www.mastercard.ca. This information has been available for more than two years. [There is a now similar website in the U.S. with more than one-hundred pages of rate schedules].
WAYTOOHIGH: Only two years? Why was MasterCard so secretive before that? Regardless, the merchant has no way of knowing what the interchange rate will be at the time of sale and therefore cannot make an educated decision about whether to accept the card. There is no transparency, and those website rate schedules are unclear and confusing. If MasterCard was honest, they would easily post the exact interchange fee as part of every charge card receipt (right under the sales tax breakdown).
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: When interchange was regulated in Australia, it led to reduced card benefits to consumers and there is no evidence that retailers passed on savings in reduced prices.
WAYTOOHIGH: To allege that a reduction in overhead costs for an entire country’s merchants would not result in lower prices is to allege a price-fixing conspiracy among all merchants. If so-called “cardholder benefits” were only available because of a price-fixing conspiracy between issuing banks, we should not lose sleep over the disappearance of those benefits when the conspiracy is busted up. The rule of law is what matters, not cardholder benefits.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard Worldwide has a PIN-based debit payment solution – Maestro(R) – used by more than 652 million cardholders in over 100 countries.
WAYTOOHIGH: Perhaps, but that doesn’t justify the price-fixing conspiracy and it doesn’t justify forcing merchants to pay supracompetitive interchange fees. MasterCard and its issuers don’t get a blank check just because they provide some benefits. Banks would need to provide debit cards even if they didn’t get interchange fees. Otherwise, it would be like banks providing a checking account but no checks.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard Canada is preparing to expand its global debit processing system in Canada where it would deliver compelling benefits to Canadian consumers and merchants.
WAYTOOHIGH: MasterCard is only increasing its market power so that it can continue to force supracompetitive interchange fees on merchants.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: Using Maestro, Canadian consumers could use debit all over the world.
WAYTOOHIGH: See previous two arguments.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: Accepting Maestro means Canadian merchants could accept international travelers’ debit cards.
WAYTOOHIGH: See above.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard will provide technological advancements including greater security and fraud protections, innovations
WAYTOOHIGH: See above.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard operates a global debit infrastructure with centralized operations that run 24/7. The system delivers significantly greater scale than Canada’s incumbent debit network. It has had zero downtime in more than seven years.
WAYTOOHIGH: See above.
—
MASTERCARD CANADA: MasterCard will create competition in the Canadian debit market where it has never existed.
WAYTOOHIGH: MasterCard is not talking about competition for merchant acceptance, only “competition” for issuing banks, which has the effect of increasing interchange rates at the expense of merchants. Payment cards are a two-sided market (issuance and acceptance) and when MasterCard, Visa and the member banks talk about so-called “competition,” they’re never talking about the merchant side of the market.
Credit Card Executive Attendees at The White House
April 22, 2009According to Reuters, this is the list of credit card industry executives expected to attend the Presidential White House meeting on Thursday, April 23rd.
- Larry Sharnak – American Express, Executive Vice President and General Manager, Consumer Cards
- Richard Struthers – Bank of America, President, Global Card Services
- Lloyd Wirshba – Barclaycard US, Chief Executive Officer
- Ryan Schneider – Capital One Financial Corp, President of Cards
- Paul Galant – Citigroup, CEO, N.A. Cards
- David Nelms – Discover Financial Services, CEO
- Patrick Burke – HSBC Card and Retail Services, Senior Vice President and Chief Operations Officer
- Gordon Smith – JPMorgan Chase & Co, CEO, Chase Card Services
- Christopher McWilton – MasterCard Worldwide, President, US Markets
- Pam Joseph – US Bancorp, Vice Chairman, Payments
- David Bohne – USAA President, USAA Savings Bank
- William Sheedy – VISA USA Inc, Global Head of Strategy
- Kevin Rhein – Wells Fargo & Co, Division President, Wells Fargo Card Services and Consumer Lending
CREDIT CARD INTERCHANGE FEE, MERCHANT-DISCOUNT ANTITRUST LITIGATION CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
April 20, 2009Click here to view the consolidated complaint.
TWITTER: Follow @WayTooHigh Recent “Tweets”
April 18, 2009
- Credit Executives Are Summoned To White House (via Nancy Trejos and Binyamin Appelbaum Washington Post) http://ow.ly/366P
- Congress is trying to rein in other abusive credit card fees, but if they don’t address interchange, they’ll miss the biggest threat of all
- $2,100,000,000 Earned in JUST the 1st Q by JP Morgan Chase. How much derived from antiquated credit card interchange fees? http://ow.ly/33hm
- Q: Why hasn’t MasterCard, Visa, Chase, CitiGroup, BofA, etc… not been shut down for collusion and credit card price-gouging. A: Dunno
- Inside The Campaign To Oust Bank of America’s Ken Lewis: Video – http://ow.ly/3d2f
- Look out: Credit cards unleash big rate hikes http://ow.ly/3d2H
- If mortgage rates continue to decline, interest rates being lowered, why are Visa and MasterCard’s credit card interchange fees soaring?
- You know it’s a good day for consumers and retailers when Visa publicly expresses extreme disappointment: http://ow.ly/2DdO
- White House calls in credit card industry – http://ow.ly/3c5d
- Dow ends best 6 weeks since 1938 on econ hopes –
- In another gesture to vulnerable consumers, the House and Senate could take up a credit card bill of rights bill. – http://ow.ly/3c53
- Question for merchants: Credit card processing fees are too high because? Tweet your experience with interchange fees @wayTooHigh
- Encouraging Credit Card Holders to Leave Should Result in Interchange Fee Refunds – http://ow.ly/3c3k
- RT @katbuilder: Fight back with banks on charging high bank fees!!
- This Merchants Payments Coalition / UnfairCreditCardFees.com video explains why MasterCard and Visa are the new enemies http://ow.ly/2BH8
- Visa / MasterCard’s long history of anticomptitive price-fixing corrupts smart biz thinking; the marketplace should control competition
- Some Bank of America credit card rates increasing: What you can do http://tinyurl.com/cm43o4
- Q: How can banks (MasterCard / Visa) cite “competitive pressures” regarding need for soaring credit card rates? They own the Monopoly board!
- TARP-fed Banks Face Scrutiny on Credit Card Interest, Fees (USBanker) http://ow.ly/390O
- For balance, to represent the millions of merchants (consumers) at the White House credit card meeting consider inviting Mitch Goldstone
- We will be Tweeting non-stop on planned White House meeting on Thurs w/ credit card execs and URGE INTERCHANGE DISCUSSION http://ow.ly/38Q1
- Peter Barnes, Senior Washington Correspondent at FOXBusiness reports on White House / credit card banking exec meeting – http://ow.ly/38Pt
- 4 Karey Wutkowski,Patrick Rucker at Reuters NOTE: Any White House meeting with credit card cos MUST discuss interchange = $60bln annual fee
- White House to meet with credit card execs-sources (Reuters) http://ow.ly/38Oi
- Dow ends best 6 weeks since 1938 on econonic hopes
- MasterCard increased its network access and brand usage fee from 0.5 cents per transaction to 1.85 cents, a 270% increase http://ow.ly/2LYl
- Companies encourage cell phone recycling as Earth Day approaches (only 10% of cell phones were recycled on ’07) http://ow.ly/2VOG
- Barclays Bank exclusive VISA Black card for THREE mln consumers = tool designed to generate HIGHER interchange fees http://ow.ly/2FAg
- Why merchants & consumers aren’t Tweeting, blogging support for Visa, MasterCard & bank credit card Interchange fees: http://ow.ly/2sjT
- Other credit card fee reforms are necessary, but don’t forget about the ~$60,000,000,000 interchange tax on businesses / consumers
- Did Visa and MasterCard create a non-competitive environment in which businesses cannot negotiate for lower interchange rates? #credit
- “A Quiet Windfall For U.S. Banks” (via Washington Post, Amit R. Paley) – http://ow.ly/2Gjq
- The credit card interchange fee is the biggest hidden tax (~$60 bln) you’ve never head of, until now: http://ow.ly/2XC7
- Credit card companies are squeezing consumers in ways big and small – http://ow.ly/2R1o (consumer action)
- This Merchants Payments Coalition / UnfairCreditCardFees.com video explains why MasterCard and Visa are the new enemies http://ow.ly/2lwa
- RT @EFFIE325: @EVERYONE CREDIT CARD COMPANIES SHOULD BE GIVING PEOPLE SOME TYPE OF RELIEF INSTEAD OF RUINING THEM WRITE TO CONGRESS!
- RT @JeffCole53: …credit card companies are like crack dealers, they ruin people’s lives, and then want to sell them even more of the drug
- Avg. American household paid $427 in credit card interchange fees last year. Total interchange fee revenues have tripled since 2001.
- RT @geidas In addition to all the other fees, credit card banks charge merchants a 2% transaction fee on every purchase http://htxt.it/HTAW
- Anatomy of How Technology Should Reduce MasterCard and Visa’s Member Banks’ Credit Card interchange Fees – http://ow.ly/2HrO #congress #bank
- Congress can’t fix the financial services industry without reforming huge, hidden credit card interchange fees. #banking #congress
- “Pres Obama campaigned on credit card reforms, Fed ruled that their practices are unfair and deceptive” – http://ow.ly/368t (WashPost)
- Credit Executives Are Summoned To White House (via Nancy Trejos and Binyamin Appelbaum Washington Post) http://ow.ly/366N
- Retailers are waging a no-holds barred campaign seeking government regulation of card acceptance fees and interchange. http://ow.ly/2TnY
- Congress can’t fix the financial services industry without reforming huge, hidden Visa / MasterCard, member banks’ interchange fees
- Credit Card Execs Summoned to White House Meeting Next Thursday
- in 2008, Americans paid twice as much in interchange fees than in credit card late fees and three times ATM fees!
- Citigroup revenues neraly doubled to $24.79 billion in JUST the 1st Q. How much was derived from excessive credit card interchange fees?
- Merchant interchange fees cover reward points for credit cards; when banks force cardholders to close accounts, NO REFUND of paid rewards
- Merchants (consumers) are paying the interchange credit card fees, which includes funding reward points, but banks keep when accounts closed
- Financial Services Committee Chair, Barney Frank said curbs on credit-card “abuses” are among his panel’s priorities. http://ow.ly/2XAx
- More Reasons to Worry About Credit Card Companies (Morgan Housel, Motley Fool) http://ow.ly/2MsJ
- Retailers across the nation are calling for interchange independence UnfairCreditCardFees.com
- innovations in electronic payments should increase effeciencies and lower fees, that’s how non-monopoly cartels work
- Ecommerce companies, like ScanMyPhotos.com and millions of others are forced to accept Visa and MaterCard; they wield 80% market power.
- Convenience store owners call for card-fee action http://ow.ly/33jT
- U.S. Rep. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) introduced a bill in the last Congress to prohibit these unfair credit card rules http://ow.ly/33j2
- Undue profiteering’s in the (credit) cards (via Sean Flynn, Boston Herald) – #banking #mastercard #visa – http://ow.ly/33iM
- Can’t fix the economy and help small businesses without addressing the banks anticompetitive credit card interchange fees
- RT @jesserz: JP Morgan Chase…making billions while people lose jobs. Justice prevails!
- $2,100,000,000 Earned in JUST the 1st Q by JP Morgan Chase. How much derived from antiquated credit card interchange fees? http://ow.ly/33ha
- JP Morgan Chase, named defendant in our merchant antitrust class-action lawsuit against credit card cos reports 1st Q earnings $2.1 bln
- JP Morgan Chase – Earnings. Video (Bloomberg) http://ow.ly/33gG
- RT @krishutchinson: Wells fargo card activator just hung up on me because I wouldn’t join the credit protection program….
- RT @bostongal48: @waytoohigh EVERYTHING IS WAYTOO HIGH
- Merchants: Socked by Credit Card Fees They Can’t See http://ow.ly/2M1E. Follow along on our 4-year blog: http://www.WayTooHigh.com
- Using Twitter as forum to humanize and as advocacy channel in battle against Visa, MasterCard credit card fees #banks #credit WayTooHigh.com
- Visa and MasterCard’s fees MUST be stopped. Now that the U.S. Taxpapers own banks, interchange should disappear
- Visa and MasterCard, two ‘competitors’ announce price increases of nearly 300 percent at the same time in a recession? – http://ow.ly/2LYH
- NY Times: Small-Business Owners Lobby to Cut Credit Card Fees – http://ow.ly/2GqM #MasterCard #Visa #banking #credit
- Global economic recession worst since Great Depression, yet, banking credit card interchange fees still rising http://ow.ly/2Dl9
- Little transparency for interchange fees that banks pay each other for each credit, debit card and ATM transaction made by customers.
- “Small-Business Owners Lobby to Cut Credit Card Fees” 9via New York Times, by JANE BIRNBAUM) http://ow.ly/2GkF
- “The Credit Card Fee That Will Fleece You,” cost of using charge cards overseas could add 5% to your purchase – http://ow.ly/2GhW
- Homeowners taking advantage of record-low mortgages, consumers benefit from lower interest rates, BUT, INTERCHANGE FEES AT RECORD LEVEL
- More info visit WayTooHigh.com – the credit card interchange report Lead plaintiff, ScanMyPhotos.com has 4+ yrs of data http://ow.ly/32pQ
- Seeking transparancy of Visa asnd MasterCard interchange rates. There is transparacy in Europe and AUS.
- Rules by Visa and MasterCard are more than 1700 PAGES. Can’t discount for cash, can’t surcharge. can’t print out on receipt the fees
- Tweeting on local and national small business leaders discussing the looming threat to economy by hidden credit card fees – interchange
- Fighting interchange fees as Visa and Mastercard continue to raise credit card merchant interchange fees payment expense up 800+% since 1995
- Seeing D.C. support. Petro industry had $3.4 bln in profits last year. $7.6 bln in credit card fees.
- One PA family business saw $4.6 mln in credit card fees, $1.0 mln more than prior year. Fed Up with Visa and MasterCard
- Impact of uncontrolled crdit card fees on supermarkets and Main Street is devistating. Retailers are “madder than hell” at credit card cos.
- Interchange is a nationwide proble,. Supermarkets after tax profit is about 1-2%, thus LESS THAN COST FOR CREDIT CARD FEES = LOSS
- PA state wide trade assn is talking. Own about 6,000 stores in PA. Over past 5 years, members said interchaneg is fastest growing TAX
- POLAND ABOLISHED INTERCHANGE FEES. EU rate is about 0.30%. U.S. about 2.0% for credit card merchant interchange fees
- ONLY ABOUT 13% is used to cover COST OF INTERCHANGE electronic payment fees. U.S. pays HIGHEST RATE in WORLD
- Use your debit card with rewards benefit yields HIGHER INTERCHANGE FEES.
- WHEN YOU PAY CASH, low interchange fee card, FOOD STAMPS, CHECKS, cover high reward cards (signature affinity cards)
- When you write a check. NO INTERCHANGE FEE. Mercjhant, however only gets ~98% back from credit card fees
- CONSUMERS don’t know about interchange fees. About 2% per transactions. [about 100 separate rates].
- FIGHT against unfair credit card fees. Seeking legislative action. Credit card interchange fees HIDDEN.
- Taylor West intro: Lyle Beckwith, National Assn Convienence Stores (NACS) representing retailers nationwide
- Stand by for live Tweeting from NEWS CONFERENCE [ Pennsylvania Retailers Urge Rep. Gerlach to Take Action] #Mastercard #Visa #banking
- Retailers are pushing Congress to challenge the credit card industry’s little-known “interchange” fees, http://ow.ly/31Gn
- Apple is about to sell its 1 billionth iPhone app, but think of all those micro-payment credit card interchange fees on 99-cent orders!
- MasterCard, Visa and other bank card customers paid $14.6 billion in 2008 just in penalties http://ow.ly/2ODF
- @WayTooHigh will be Tweeting LIVE from today’s press event. #MasterCard #Visa #banking #charge #credit card #interchange #bank fees
- 11:15 (PDT). Today, April 16 at 2:15pm – Pennsylvania Retailers Urge Rep. Gerlach to Take Action http://ow.ly/324j
- Telephone Press Conference Calling on Rep. Gerlach to Stand with Pennsylvania Consumers and Small Businesses – Credit Card Fees
- Unfair and anti-competitive interchange fees are crippling businesses http://ow.ly/323J
- Local and national small business leaders will host a conference call with state reporters to discuss hidden credit card fees; interchange.
- Telephonic Press Conference, Thursday, April 16th, at 2:15 PM Eastern Dial-in number: 800-895-0198, Passcode: PENN**** http://ow.ly/323m
- It’s not often that the credit card industry faces a defeat in D.C. until now, watch video http://ow.ly/2FLz #charge #banks #TARP #antitrust
- Local Retailers Ask Rep. Gerlach to Stand With Them, Rein in Fees That Hurt Pennsylvania Consumers, Small Businesses http://ow.ly/323j
- RT @geidas: @WayTooHigh I’m doing a story on the fees. Dan Kelly, Reading Eagle, PA, can you contact me at dkelly@readingeagle.com.
- Growing List of Reasons to Lower and End Interchange Fees http://ow.ly/2DmH
- @WayTooHigh edited by Mitch Goldstone, pres & CEO, ScanMyPhotos.com. Blog launched in ’05 http://www.WayTooHigh.com http://ow.ly/2MeJ
- – Retailers cry foul on credit card fees http://ow.ly/31Gc –
- Bailed-Out Banks Face Probe Over Fee Hikes – MSNBC http://ow.ly/2Me2
- retailers under intense pressure, interchange fees = credit card cos charge retailers every time a charge card is used http://ow.ly/2nWG
- Q: Why hasn’t MasterCard, Visa, Chase, CitiGroup, BofA, etc… not been shut down for collusion and credit card price-gouging. A: Dunno
- RT @marktzk: USAir is unilaterally canceling my BofA Visa miles card and issuing a Barclay’s Mastercard instead. Looking for a new card now
- Credit card-banking lobbyists, Bank of America, Chase, Citigroup, Wells Fargo, Visa, Mastercard et al won’t like this: http://ow.ly/2M2T
- What’s wrong with credit card companies’ argument for higher interchange fees to fund frequent flyer rewards http://ow.ly/2MkU
- RT @geidas In addition to all the other fees, credit card banks charge merchants a 2% transaction fee on every purchase http://htxt.it/HTAW
- Take a second to help out WayTooHigh! Vote for them on Twibs at http://tinyurl.com/dldx7v
- Did you know that there are no electronic payment merchant interchange fees for check clearing?
- RT @NiamhD: I really hate when you check your bank account and the back have taken notified fees that you weren’t notified about…
- RT @crunchysue: @jnpdx The government is run by credit card companies, and is not trying to get us out of debt at all.
- RT @EFFIE325: @EVERYONE I’M ANGRY AT CREDIT CARD COMPANIES…THEY ARE RUINING ARE SCORES BY REDUCING OUR LIMITS PEOPLE COMPLAIN TO CONGRESS
- RT @SeanMiller: Does anyone else hate Bank of America? 8 Overdraft Fees? Now I’ve been on hold all morning. Sweet.
- @debs2005 – Like milions of retailers, ScanMyPhotos.com is forced to accept Visa and MasterCard (80% market power) 100% online biz is cc.
- Question for retailers: Credit card processing fees are too high because? Tweet your experience with interchange fees @wayTooHigh
- We’re a real company that is fed up with credit card fees; behind the scenes at ScanMyPhotos.com. – http://ow.ly/2YDi
- Banks Hike Fees Despite Bailout Billions; Consumers and Congressional Panel Ask Why #mastercard #visa http://ow.ly/2M0U
- Credit Card, Bank Fee Hikes Spark Outrage (ALICE GOMSTYN, ABC NEWS Business Unit) http://ow.ly/2M0G
- NACS: New Credit Card Fees ‘Beyond Outrageous’ (National Association of Convenience Stores) http://ow.ly/2LY7
- AARP Magazine: Protect Your Priceless Photos – Let a scanning company digitize your pics. It’s cheap and easy as can be – http://ow.ly/2YoL
- in 2008, Americans paid twice as much in interchange fees than in credit card late fees and three times ATM fees!
- “No rhyme or reason to credit card fees” [via Stephen Campbell, New Brunswick Business Journal] http://ow.ly/2Dk5
- Watch What Congress Needs to Know About Interchange Fees (via http://www.UnfairCreditCard…) http://ow.ly/2Gpj #banking
- Where are the Pro-Interchange Fee Bloggers and Tweets? http://ow.ly/2GnF #charge #retail #economy
- Annual hidden credit card interchange tax on American consumers has skyrocketed from $25 billion to nearly $62 billion http://ow.ly/2Gkg
- good days for consumers and retailers when Visa publicly expresses extreme disappointment: http://ow.ly/2nKe
- with signs of global economic metldown, how are Visa, MasterCard, banks maintaining soaring merchant interchange fees? http://ow.ly/2GiE
- Visa Inc. Warns of Multiple Threats to F’09, Among the many risks = penalties related to litigation settlements http://ow.ly/2Gi9
- Financial Services Committee Chair, Barney Frank said curbs on credit-card “abuses” are among his panel’s priorities. http://ow.ly/2XA3
- Chris Dodd, chair, Senate Banking Committee, said banks were using lax rules to “gouge” customers http://ow.ly/2Xy1
- Bank of America to Raise Fee on Credit-Card Transfers [Bloomberg, By David Mildenberg] http://ow.ly/2Xxl
- Credit Card Interchange Fees: Issues and Answers (Merchants Payments Coalition)
- About the Merchants Payments Coalition – http://ow.ly/2XqV
- Happy that credit card interchange issue is being noticed by Chris Dodd and D.C. helps establish his independence from banking industry
- RT @ThreeDegrees: I hate bank fees. #hate #bank
- Outrageous interchange fees cost Americans $2 for every $100 they spend – whether or not they use a credit card – http://ow.ly/2zQz
- RT @siriuslyheather: Damnit, how I hate bank fees! :((((((((((((
- The credit card interchange fee is the biggest hidden tax (~$60 bln) you’ve never head of, until now: http://ow.ly/2tDX
- Did you Know: The actual cost to transact an electronic payment is a tiny fraction of the total fees collected
- The credit card interchange fee = biggest tax you’ve never heard of. Nearly $2 of every $100 charged goes directly to credit card industry
- RT @highking1979: Credit Card companies have no business receiving bailout funds. They charge enough.
- Merchant interchange fees cover reward points for credit cards; when banks force cardholders to close accounts, NO REFUND of paid rewards
- Rescued Banks Not Passing the Bailout Onto Customers who face steep increases in rates (avg CC int rate up 12.4% – http://ow.ly/2VE3
- The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is reviewing if Bank of America Corp violated federal securities law http://ow.ly/2OBg
- This is the top ranked link from @WayTooHigh mastercard and Visa Tweets: http://ow.ly/2M35
- RT @Whynatte: The US Airways flight attendant literally spent 15 minutes trying to sell a VISA card to passengers over loudspeaker.
- Retailers are waging a no-holds barred campaign seeking government regulation of card acceptance fees and interchange. http://ow.ly/2TnX
- RT @SuziB777 So they are saying the economy is coming back please tell my bus. bank account isn’t seeing any comebacks,,,, higher more fees
- RT @LotsaNews: [CNN][ Bank fees on the rise: CNN’s Mary Snow reports on growing anger over rising interest ra.. http://tinyurl.com/dkzd9c
- RT @DebtLawyer: Credit card companies are inclined to settle with card holders who are experiencing a genuine financial hardship.
- Barclays Bank exclusive VISA Black card for THREE mln consumers = tool designed to generate HIGHER interchange fees http://ow.ly/2FLj
- It’s not often that the credit card industry faces a defeat in D.C. until now, watch video http://ow.ly/2lw5
- You know it’s a good day for consumers and retailers when Visa publicly expresses extreme disappointment: http://ow.ly/2DdJ
- not often that the credit card industry faces a defeat in D.C. until now, watch video http://ow.ly/2nKR
- Thanks to Twitter, retailers and consumers have instant updates in the war against Credit Card Cos; Visa, MasterCard and its member banks
- When Visa and MasterCard began, there wasn’t Twitter to provide instant updates on their anticompetitive price-fixing.
- Credit Card Companies Pushing Back Against Udall’s Reform Bill http://ow.ly/2SkX
- RT @ms_elyse: just watched this documentary on Showtime called Maxed Out about credit card companies and debt. Everyone should watch it
- RT @mikearama: @waytoohigh Credit card companies broken contracts http://tiny.cc/O57LE #credit #creditcards
- Capital One hiked customer rates that it once had guaranteed would forever remain at 4.9% fixed to 17.9% variable – http://ow.ly/2R1C
- in 2008, Americans paid twice as much in interchange fees than in credit card late fees and three times ATM fees!
- The credit card interchange fee = biggest tax you’ve never heard of. Nearly $2 of every $100 charged goes directly to credit card industry
- Merchants (consumers) are paying the interchange credit card fees, which includes funding reward points, but banks keep when accounts closed
- MasterCard: The Most Absurd Statement in the History of the Credit Card Industry? http://ow.ly/2Gnb #retail #ecommerce #banking
- Economic Crisis has no Pricing Impact on Interchange Fees #mastercard #visa #charge #bank http://ow.ly/2Gin
- If you’re a retailer paying credit card merchant interchange fees watch MAXED OUT – NOW ON DVD http://ow.ly/2GhB
- This Merchants Payments Coalition / UnfairCreditCardFees.com video explains why MasterCard and Visa are the new enemies http://ow.ly/2i3C
- Credit card companies are squeezing consumers in ways big and small – http://ow.ly/2R1a (consumer action)
- More college students run up credit card debt for tuition, books http://ow.ly/2R0N
- Mitch Goldstone, president & CEO, ScanMyPhotos.com (editor WayTooHigh.com) on Fox News (Jan 19) http://bit.ly/uYLAP
- “Visa, MasterCard, who continue to add on fees and rules… Stand Up to Big Banks, Fix Credit Card Interchange Fees!” http://ow.ly/2zQh
- Web100.com selected ScanMyPhotos.com (#16) for the Photo 100 list of the web’s best photography sites: http://ow.ly/2Oon
- RT @briana9: I hate Bank of America. 5 overdraft fees of $35/each in one day should not be legal!
- Merchants (consumers) pay interchange credit card fees, includes funding reward pts, but banks keep when accounts closed http://ow.ly/2FAp
- Barclays Bank exclusive VISA Black card for THREE mln consumers = tool designed to generate HIGHER interchange fees http://ow.ly/2FAf
- What exactly does “Interchange” credit card fees mean? – http://ow.ly/2Ahd
- Credit card-banking lobbyists, Bank of America, Chase, Citigroup, Wells Fargo, Visa, Mastercard et al won’t like this: http://ow.ly/2D8Z
- RT @Denrael: Growing List of Reasons to Lower and End Interchange Fees http://ow.ly/2DmF (via @WayTooHigh)
- RT @mcmilker: @WayTooHigh Thx for the retweet on banks!
- RT @MortTwain: @WayTooHigh I just watched this video outlining credit card company abuses. Everybody should see it! Sharpen your pitchforks
- This Merchants Payments Coalition / UnfairCreditCardFees.com video explains why MasterCard and Visa are the new enemies http://ow.ly/2BH4
- SEC reviewing if Bank of America violated federal securities law http://ow.ly/2OBb
- Congress can’t fix the financial services industry without reforming huge, hidden credit card interchange fees. #banking #congress
- Credit card companies won’t like this: http://ow.ly/2M2S
- Congress can’t fix the financial services industry without reforming huge, hidden Visa / MasterCard, member banks’ interchange fees
- DOUBLE TAXATION: MasterCard and Visa gift cards charge purchase fees ~$5.95 plus merchant pays interchange fees
- MasterCard, Visa and other bank card customers paid $14.6 billion in 2008 just in penalties http://ow.ly/2ODr
- The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is reviewing if Bank of America Corp violated federal securities law http://ow.ly/2OB2
- Are Visa and MasterCard illegally fixing the fees charged to merchants who accept their cards? #banking #credit
- Did Visa and MasterCard create a non-competitive environment in which businesses cannot negotiate for lower interchange rates? #credit
- More bad news for MasterCard, Visa and the banking industry: Minnesota court ruled in favor of Al Franken in his 2008 Senate race
- NY Times: Small-Business Owners Lobby to Cut Credit Card Fees – http://ow.ly/2GqC #MasterCard #Visa #banking #credit
- This is the top ranked link from @WayTooHigh mastercard and Visa Tweets: http://ow.ly/2M34
- “Massive cuts in idle consumer credit lines could equal hell for credit card processors like Visa and MasterCard” http://ow.ly/2Mt3
- RT @thewuzz: i hate banks and stupid bank fees
- Growing List of Reasons to Lower and End Interchange Fees http://ow.ly/2DmF
- MasterCard increased its network access and brand usage fee from 0.5 cents per transaction to 1.85 cents, a 270% increase http://ow.ly/2LYg
- Non interchange. win 1 for the entrepreneur, ScanMyPhotos.com named #16 – Web100.com Top 100 photography-themed websites http://ow.ly/2MxZ
- “two-pronged battle sucking the life out of the credit card industry” http://ow.ly/2MtO
- More Reasons to Worry About Credit Card Companies (Morgan Housel, Motley Fool) http://ow.ly/2Mst
- Congratulations to United States Senator-elect Al Franken
- Good bye credit card Interchange Fees!!! Court ruled in favor of Al Franken, one less (R) Senator
- More bad news for MasterCard, Visa and the banking industry: Minnesota court ruled in favor of Al Franken in his 2008 Senate race
- Breaking News: Franken Declared Leading Vote-Getter in Minn. Senate Race
- What’s wrong with credit card companies’ argument for higher interchange fees to fund frequent flyer rewards http://ow.ly/2Mku
- @WayTooHigh edited by Mitch Goldstone, pres & CEO, ScanMyPhotos.com. Blog launched in ’05 http://www.WayTooHigh.com http://ow.ly/2MeD
- Visa and MasterCard, two ‘competitors’ announce price increases of nearly 300 percent at the same time in a recession? – http://ow.ly/2LYx
- Are Bank of America and Citicorp planning another fee hike and trying to get it done before the new legislation? Is it retroactive?
- Bailed-Out Banks Face Probe Over Fee Hikes – MSNBC http://ow.ly/2MdY
- Visa, MasterCard credit card interchange fees are excessive and abusive, but their 80% market power = don’t care
- Visa and MasterCard’s fees MUST be stopped. Now that the U.S. Taxpapers own banks, interchange should disappear
- Did you know, when you use your debit Pin-based card as a credit card, your funds are removed just as fast, and retailers pay MORE
- Q: Why hasn’t MasterCard, Visa, Chase, CitiGroup, BofA, etc… not been shut down for collusion and credit card price-gouging. A: Dunno
- Merchants: Socked by Credit Card Fees They Can’t See http://ow.ly/2M1C. Follow along on our 4-year blog: http://www.WayTooHigh.com
- Merchants: New Yorkers Socked by Credit Card Fees They Can’t See http://ow.ly/2M1u
- complaints about bank fee spikes have prompted the Congressional Oversight Panel to launch a probe into the issue.
- Banks Hike Fees Despite Bailout Billions; Consumers and Congressional Panel Ask Why #mastercard #visa http://ow.ly/2M0S
- Credit Card, Bank Fee Hikes Spark Outrage (ALICE GOMSTYN, ABC NEWS Business Unit) http://ow.ly/2M0y @WayTooHigh
- RT @MuchMoreThanMom: RT @tommytrc BoA Hikes Rates On Millions Of Credit Card Customers [Bank Of America] http://tinyurl.com/dkp5oe
- RT @loupnoir: Rt @CReporter RT @consumersunion: BofA coy about how many got letter re big credit card rate increase. http://bit.ly/3GNfqF
- Using Twitter as forum to humanize and as advocacy channel in battle against Visa, MasterCard credit card fees #banks #credit WayTooHigh.com
- innovations in electronic payments should increase effeciencies and lower fees, that’s how non-monopoly cartels work
- NACS: New Credit Card Fees ‘Beyond Outrageous’ (National Association of Convenience Stores) http://ow.ly/2LY2
- U.S. Senator Christopher Dodd, @SenChrisDodd, U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs is following @WayTooHigh
- David Buckner faints on Glenn Beck’s show – Fox Network News – Watch video. JUST IN… http://ow.ly/2LRi
- Banks are like drug dealers – they can’t resist Interchange profiteering; leading to billions in toxic creditcard debt : U.S. is bailing out
- Avg. American household paid $427 in credit card interchange fees last year. Total interchange fee revenues have tripled since 2001.
- Chase added a $10 monthly fee and increased the minimum payment from 2% to 5% for those who carry a large balance.
- Other credit card fee reforms are necessary, but don’t forget about the ~$60,000,000,000 interchange tax on businesses / consumers
- “A Quiet Windfall For U.S. Banks” (via Washington Post, Amit R. Paley) – http://ow.ly/2Gjk #credit #banks #mastercard #visa
Why Credit Card Companies Full of Hot Air
April 13, 2009
A leading argument to sustain soaring merchant interchange credit card fees is to cover the cost of affinity reward programs. The banks were passing along the frequent flyer reward costs to merchants, and thus consumers, who are the ones buying the merchandise.
Now that millions of cardholders are losing their accounts, those rewards are being terminated as well. When a cardholder is delinquent on their credit card bills by even a day, they risk losing all their accumulated reward points as well.
Well, what is it? If interchange fees are lowered, Visa and MasterCard’s argument is that consumers will have to pay higher fees. As it is, the banks are already raising rates, closing accounts and changing the terms with wanton disregard for their customers.
Where are the Pro-Interchange Fee Bloggers and Tweets?
April 9, 2009In baseball, it is easy to keep score – look at the scoreboard. In politics – read the polls. But, for interchange fees, run by the banking cartel, there is little notice, other than those bi-annual fee “adjustment” letters. As retailers continue battling against MasterCard and Visa – the two leading credit card associations with 80% market power and its member banks, it is also easy to keep score.
With nearly 1,300 postings on WayTooHigh.com– The Credit Card Interchange Report, we have yet to read any pro-interchange fee blogs that weren’t connected with the banking industry and their paid advocacy firms.
Well, there is always that one “pro consumer,” “pro competition” group that “enjoys the financial support of Visa,” but that really shouldn’t count. Where are the merchants championing 1.7% interchange fee rates, and challenging WayTooHigh.com?
Where are the U.S. retailers thanking Visa® and MasterCard® for charging among the highest rates in the world, while abroad, the interchange fees are 0.7%, 0.5% and even 0.0% – there are no interchange fee for debit PIN-based cards in Canada.
The reason for such silence?
Merchants understand they are being taken on a ride when cardholders present their affinity frequent flyer cards. The merchants, and thus the consumers are paying for these perks and the nearly $40 billion a year in interchange fees. Since we were the first to launch the merchant interchange litigation back in mid-2005, there have been no pro-interchange fee blogs that we are familiar with. That speaks volumes about our cause and the unfair fees.
Edited by Mitch Goldstone, president and CEO – ScanMyPhotos.com
Follow WayTooHigh.com on Twitter
April 4, 2009Follow WayTooHigh.com on Twitter for instant updates and more at Twitter.com/WayTooHigh
Another Argument For Zero Interchange Fees: Gift Cards
April 3, 2009Have you noticed the growing prominence of gift card kiosks filling up the end caps at many supermarkets and other retail locations? You can purchase gift cards for a variety of products, restaurants, attractions and unrelated shopping experiences.
Here is how gift cards work when you buy it at a supermarket or other large retailer:
You choose the value and brand, then their sales clerk rings up your order and validates the electronic payment card. Think of all the payment networks that are involved? There is an acquiring and issuing institution as the supermarket transaction is processed by a third party that pays the company issuing the card. There are added costs to print, merchandise and process the transactions. Yet, there are no added fees, unlike if you select a Visa or MasterCard branded gift card, where you pay an upfront fee of about $4.99 or higher, plus being forced to pay a monthly charge for non-use and other fees; think of Ticketmaster and all their extra charges.
The difference between the store electronic gift cards and those branded by Visa and MasterCard are they are without standard interchange fees. Those store-branded plastic gift cards are being transacted through an electronic payment network, but also without a monthly “maintenance” fee that Visa and MasterCard can separately impose.
Also absent are those mentioned fraud costs and other extra fees that Visa and MasterCard regularly present to try justifying their nearly 1.7% merchant interchange fee for transacting an electronic payment on the two leading credit card payment networks in the U.S., overseas, the interchange fee can be as low as .5% in Australia, .7% in the UK and zero in Canada for Pin-based debit card transactions.
I also don’t think regular store-branded cards charge a per transaction fee, which Visa and MasterCard can tack on of about 35-cents for each charge.
Many of the store gift cards can be used at multiple locations and even for ordering on their website for electronic payment transactions. Airline gift cards can be used at multiple airports, hotel gift cards can be used system wide at all their locations, yet they are without those interchange fees.
Micro balances on Visa and MasterCard gift cards are nearly a pure tax, as it is challenging to use those small amounts. And often merchants can’t process those small amounts. I tried it at a Chevron gas station, when I had a 35-cent balance and the card was denied. However, look at Starbucks and thousands of other merchants who will give you cash back. In California, it is a state law that when asked, stores must give shoppers cash back when the balance on the store gift card falls below ten dollars.
The moral is that retailers understand that gift cards are a benefit and provided value added sales, while the banks use credit and debit cards as a decades-long scheme to take on added fees just because they can. As more attention is being publicized on this issue, Visa and MasterCard’s monopolistic 80% market power and cartel-like control are angering many.
FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: Twitter.com/WayTooHigh
Visa and MasterCard’s April Fool’s Day Interchange Saga
April 1, 2009Although the letter was dated in mid-March, ScanMyPhotos.com, like millions of other merchants received the new rate schedules just days before the April 1st increase. As is a tradition, twice each year, we regularly receive these letters announcing the new Visa and MasterCard merchant fees.
Even as the lead plaintiff in a merchant interchange antitrust suit against Visa, MasterCard and its major (still solvent) member banks, I have no clue what the new rates are. Now, they just direct you to a website to review the merchant interchange fee rates.
Here is the letter:
MASTERCARD WORLDWIDE INTERCHANGE RATES As of April 1, 2009 (115 pages!)
VISA USA INTERCHANGE RATES (The new, April 1, 2009 rates, although in effect are unknown, as they have yet to be updated as of 7:30 pm (PDT, Wed, April 1, 2009)